Willie Toles/Ida Toles vs. City of Dyersburg

The present appeal arises out of a zoning dispute between the plaintiff property owner and the City of Dyersburg, Tennessee. The property in question had been operated as a tavern since 1960. In 1998, the area in which the property was located was re-zoned as a residential area. At that point, the tavern became a non-conforming use. Prior to the re-zoning, the tavern's business license had expired and the beer license had also lapsed. The operator of the club applied for a beer permit but was denied based upon the fact that at the time of the re-zoning there was no business in operation on the premises. Therefore, the City determined that the premises could not be "grandfathered" into the new zoning classification. The Plaintiffs filed a Statutory Writ of Certiorari challenging the City's actions. The trial court held a trial de novo after which the City's actions were upheld.