Monica McPeek, et al. v. Melinda S. Lockhart

Case Number
E2004-01034-COA-R3-CV

Monica McPeek and Melinda S. Lockhart ("Defendant") were involved in an automobile accident. Monica McPeek and her husband, Eldridge McPeek, ("Plaintiffs" or "Ms. McPeek" and "Mr. McPeek" respectively) sued Defendant. The case was tried and the jury found Ms. McPeek to be 40% at fault for the accident and Defendant 60% at fault and awarded Ms. McPeek damages of $4,000 and Mr. McPeek zero damages. Plaintiffs appeal claiming the Trial Court erred in refusing to grant an additur or a new trial after the jury refused to award loss of consortium damages to Mr. McPeek and that the Trial Court erred by allowing the introduction of certain of Ms. McPeek's medical records. We affirm.

Authoring Judge
Judge D. Michael Swiney
Originating Judge
Judge Richard E. Ladd
Case Name
Monica McPeek, et al. v. Melinda S. Lockhart
Date Filed
Dissent or Concur
No
Download PDF Version
mcpeekm.pdf33.27 KB