Donald McArthur Carver v. State of Tennessee

The petitioner appeals the denial of his petition for post-conviction relief. He contends that he accepted his plea bargain on the condition that he would serve his ten-year sentence in the county jail. No such agreement was contained in the plea agreement or announced in open court. However, the testimony is overwhelming that trial counsel gave assurances to the petitioner that, unless his medical condition changed or he was a discipline problem, he would be allowed to serve his ten-year sentence in the county jail. We conclude the advice and assurances given by trial counsel were erroneous, as contrary to the law. But for said advice and assurances, the petitioner would not have pled guilty. We reverse the post-conviction court's denial of relief, allow the petitioner to withdraw his guilty plea, and remand for new trial.